Tabby cat sniffing LitterBond dental foam, PurrWipes and calming spray on a wooden table

Free US shipping on $39+ · 30-day returns · Secure checkout

[Legacy] Cat Toys

Catnip kickers, plush and silvervine toys in 3 or 6 packs, plus wands, a treat launcher and a tunnel.

Plush Pizza Set for Batting

A four-piece plush pizza set with a ribbed box and three face-detail slices for batting.
$24.99
Shop now

Knotted Crinkle Kicker Pillow

A soft ribbed knot pillow with catnip and crinkle paper for hugging and bunny kicks.
$19.99
Shop now

Chenille Octopus Plush Toy for Batting & Hugging

A round chenille octopus with fringe arms, catnip and a bell for batting and hugging.
$19.99
Shop now

Gray Faucet Plush Toy for Batting

A soft gray faucet-shaped plush toy with three curled ribbon tails for paw play.
$19.99
Shop now

Knitted Catnip Plush Toy for Batting & Hugging

Knitted catnip plush in Blue Cactus or Smiling Flower designs for batting and hugging.
$20.99
Shop now

Novelty Plush Toys for Batting

Six soft novelty plush shapes sized for cat paws, batting, pouncing and brief hugs.
$20.99
Shop now

Iridescent Manta Ray Plush for Batting

A shimmering lavender manta ray plush with crinkle ribbons and a fabric ball for batting.
$19.99
Shop now

Pink Radish Plush for Hugging

A round pink radish plush with a cartoon face and green feather tuft for batting and hugs.
$19.99
Shop now

Fruit Plush Toys for Batting

Soft fuzzy fruit-shaped plush toys in six playful designs for batting and pouncing.
$21.99
Shop now

Bobble Dumbbell Plush Toy for Batting

A lavender dumbbell plush with bobble ends, ribbons and a smiling face for batting.
$19.99
Shop now

Burlap Fish Batting Toy

A textured burlap-style fish plush with catnip filling for batting and carrying.
$19.99
Shop now

Zebra Stripe Kicker Pillow for Hugging

A 28 cm zebra-stripe short-plush kicker pillow with crinkle paper and valerian inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Radish Crinkle Plush for Hugging

A soft radish-shaped plush with leafy stems, crinkle paper and a bell inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Gingham Bow Black Cat Plush

A standing black cat plush with a blue gingham bow and sound inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Flying Squirrel Plush for Batting

A flying squirrel plush with crinkle paper, catnip and a fluffy gray tail for paw play.
$19.99
Shop now

Striped Tiger Kicker Plush

A long striped tiger plush with a shaggy belly and press-activated sound for kicking.
$19.99
Shop now

Pink Pig Plush Kicker

A pink pig plush kicker with woven texture, curly tail, squeaker and catnip inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Curly Wool Kicker for Hugging

A cream curly wool kicker with a feather cluster and fabric loop for paw-led play.
$19.99
Shop now

Smiling Kale Leaf Plush Toy

A smiling kale leaf plush toy with ruffled sides, bell and crinkle details for batting.
$19.99
Shop now

Lotus Root Kicker for Bunny Kicks

A long lotus root plush kicker with a gathered center, leaf end and tassel.
$27.99
Shop now

Red Onion Plush Kicker Toy for Hugging & Kicking

A tomato-red onion plush with leafy fabric, stitched face and cotton tassel for paw play.
$19.99
Shop now

Shaggy Chicken Plush for Batting

A shaggy white chicken plush with feathered wings for batting and hugs.
$19.99
Shop now

Green Stripe Feather Roller

A green-and-ivory rope roller with yellow cord accents and feathered ends.
$19.99
Shop now

Plush Character Play Pals

Four plush character choices with expressive faces and scarf, apron or bow details.
$19.99
Shop now

Blue & White Feather Rope Ball

A tightly wrapped blue-and-ivory rope ball with feathers and a bell inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Rabbit Fur Feather Mesh Toy

A fluffy ivory fur ball on lavender mesh with yellow accents and feather ends.
$19.99
Shop now

Long-Tail Bird Feather Toy

A yellow bird toy with a feather body and long orange-and-yellow ribbon tail.
$19.99
Shop now

Big-Eye Pepper Plush Toys

A big-eyed pepper plush with two rope legs, catnip filling and a bell.
$19.99
Shop now

Long-Limbed Crinkle Plush Animals

Long-limbed plush animals with striped accents, crinkle paper and a squeaker.
$24.99
Shop now

Leopard Print Tail Kicker

Long leopard-print pillow toy with a fluffy green tail, crinkle paper and catnip.
$19.99
Shop now

Rustic Ribbon-Leaf Carrot

Slim burlap-look plush carrot with ribbon leaves and crinkle paper, about 33 cm.
$19.99
Shop now

Checkerboard Long-Tail Mouse

Plush mouse toy with a woven checkerboard body and a long, fluffy tail to grab.
$19.99
Shop now

Goofy-Face Fringe Fish Plushies

Extra-long plush fish toy with a goofy face, fluffy edge and crinkle paper inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Floppy Pom-Pom Eye Snake

Long, floppy plush snake with pom-pom eyes, a jingle bell nose and a feather tail.
$19.99
Shop now

Pocket Crab & Lobster Pals

Mini plush crab or lobster with catnip and a small bell, about 13 cm.
$19.99
Shop now

Yellow Shooting Star Toy

A soft yellow plush star with a feather tail, a bell and silvervine filling.
$20.99
Shop now

Lilac Eggplant Sound Plush

Fluffy lilac plush eggplant with a soft green cap and a sound device inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Shades Pineapple Pal

A plush pineapple in sunglasses with a feather crown, a bell and silvervine knots.
$26.99
Shop now

Sparkle Shell Sea Turtle

A flat plush sea turtle with sky-blue flippers and a sparkly honeycomb shell.
$19.99
Shop now

Twist Wrapper Candy Toys

Plush wrapped-candy toy with crinkle paper, catnip and ruffled wrapper ends.
$19.99
Shop now

Red Claw Lobster Kicker

A long red plush lobster kicker with big claws, catnip and a small bell.
$19.99
Shop now

Bear & Lamb Corduroy Pillows

A flat corduroy pillow toy in a bear or lamb design with a fuzzy edge trim.
$19.99
Shop now

Felt Blossom Linen Pillow

A small linen-look kicker pillow with three felt flowers, about 14.5 cm long.
$19.99
Shop now

Floppy Ear Blossom Bunny

A pink plush bunny with huge floppy ears, a floral body and crinkle sound inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Curly Pink Grin Duck

A curly pink plush duck with a wide grin, fluffy gray wings and a bell inside.
$19.99
Shop now

Fleece Tab Hippo Plushies

A small plush hippo in taupe or gray with colorful fabric tag tabs.
$19.99
Shop now

Scallion Plush Kicker

A long, slim plush green onion kicker with a smiling face and tassel end.
$19.99
Shop now

Popcorn Chenille Duck Kicker

A chubby yellow popcorn-chenille duck kicker with crinkle paper inside.
$19.99
Shop now